• Visitors can check out the Forum FAQ by clicking this link. You have to register before you can post: click the REGISTER link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. View our Forum Privacy Policy.
  • Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

Software Supplier calculates support costs incorrectly - charging VAT on VAT

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Software Supplier calculates support costs incorrectly - charging VAT on VAT

    I'm disputing an annual invoice for software maintenance - it's the first one I've received, and I reckon they've overcharged me, so I disputed it.

    The annual charge for Support is 22% of the purchase cost of the software, and here's how they work it out:
    1. Add VAT to the Purchase Cost
    2. round up to the nearest £100
    3. calculate 22% of the total
    4. add VAT

    So, I'm paying support costs for the VAT, and a few quid I didn't even spend, then being charged VAT for it - paying VAT on the VAT.

    My question is - does this seem reasonable? I don't think it is, so I've only paid them 22% of the ex-VAT purchase price.

    The supplier is a very large well-known company, and they're not responding to emails, or the dispute case I raised on their billing portal.

    #2
    If they are a UK VAT registered company then whatever they charge you, they have to charge VAT on top of this. You're not paying "VAT on VAT", you're simply paying VAT on their support charge.

    What you are disputing is their method of calculating their support charge. How this is calculated should be in whatever contract/agreement you have with them. What does it say?

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by metageek View Post
      I'm disputing an annual invoice for software maintenance - it's the first one I've received, and I reckon they've overcharged me, so I disputed it.

      The annual charge for Support is 22% of the purchase cost of the software, and here's how they work it out:
      1. Add VAT to the Purchase Cost
      2. round up to the nearest £100
      3. calculate 22% of the total
      4. add VAT

      So, I'm paying support costs for the VAT, and a few quid I didn't even spend, then being charged VAT for it - paying VAT on the VAT.

      My question is - does this seem reasonable? I don't think it is, so I've only paid them 22% of the ex-VAT purchase price.

      The supplier is a very large well-known company, and they're not responding to emails, or the dispute case I raised on their billing portal.
      It depends whether 'purchase cost' is defined as the ex-VAT price or the inc-VAT cost. I guess they found a way to say 'support cost is 22%' rather than 'support cost is 27%'.

      Sounds a bit rough of them, to be fair.
      Taking a break from contracting

      Comment


        #4
        I think this is pretty common and I had it with a client a few months ago.

        Paid for their hosting with VAT and then when I charged them asked my accountant if I should add VAT again. She said it was up to me. If I didn't then it would be a disbursement (?) but if I wanted to add VAT to a VAT included amount then that was fine. I chose not to.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by metageek View Post
          I'm disputing an annual invoice for software maintenance - it's the first one I've received, and I reckon they've overcharged me, so I disputed it.

          The annual charge for Support is 22% of the purchase cost of the software, and here's how they work it out:
          1. Add VAT to the Purchase Cost
          2. round up to the nearest £100
          3. calculate 22% of the total
          4. add VAT

          So, I'm paying support costs for the VAT, and a few quid I didn't even spend, then being charged VAT for it - paying VAT on the VAT.

          My question is - does this seem reasonable? I don't think it is, so I've only paid them 22% of the ex-VAT purchase price.

          The supplier is a very large well-known company, and they're not responding to emails, or the dispute case I raised on their billing portal.
          Does you contract with them state whether the support charge will be 22% of the purchase price with or without VAT? That'd be where I start. If it's ambiguous, meh.
          The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world that he didn't exist

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by TheCyclingProgrammer View Post
            If they are a UK VAT registered company then whatever they charge you, they have to charge VAT on top of this. You're not paying "VAT on VAT", you're simply paying VAT on their support charge.

            What you are disputing is their method of calculating their support charge. How this is calculated should be in whatever contract/agreement you have with them. What does it say?
            I re-read the contract, and it doesn't contain all the words I heard verbally, merely quotes the annnual cost, so contractually I'm stuffed. I'm still waiting for them to respond the dispute case I raised with them, though I think they might believe it's all sorted, as the status is "Closed - Awaiting Responsible". They really do not like communicating.

            Comment

            Working...
            X