PDA

View Full Version : Has a case against any DOTAS scheme been heard in court?



nickersan
28th July 2015, 13:50
In the process of contacting my MP regarding the whole DOTAS/APN mess and while I'm pretty certain none of the arrangements I have worked through have been tested in court, I was wondering if any others have - does anyone know?

regron
28th July 2015, 14:06
Sorry, can't answer your question but just want to say good luck and glad to hear others are doing this. All I would say is drum home your personal circumstances as well, to ensure you get him/her engaged to what this legislation is doing to people and their lives. Do not let him/her get away with feeding you the cock and bull template that will certainly come from your MP via Gauke.

Oh and would be good to mention the meeting BG had with Damien Hinds !!!!! I know I will be in my follow up meet !!!

DotasScandal
28th July 2015, 14:23
Sorry, can't answer your question but just want to say good luck and glad to hear others are doing this. All I would say is drum home your personal circumstances as well, to ensure you get him/her engaged to what this legislation is doing to people and their lives. Do not let him/her get away with feeding you the cock and bull template that will certainly come from your MP via Gauke.

Oh and would be good to mention the meeting BG had with Damien Hinds !!!!! I know I will be in my follow up meet !!!

This. Make it personal. Make it his problem as much as your problem.

Iliketax
28th July 2015, 18:07
I was wondering if any others have - does anyone know?

Nothing to do with contractors, but Gemsupa Ltd is an FTT case about a DOTAS registered scheme.

webberg
29th July 2015, 17:22
The FTT and UTT listings don't particularly lend themselves to sorting by DOTAS SRN. I could do a manual search I suppose or go to some less official indices. I'll have a look.

There have been a few hearings that have considered issues like discovery, penalty, etc where a DOTAS number is in evidence.

I'm not sure if the SHIPS schemes were DOTAS registered?

Perhaps a FoI request might be easier?

nickersan
4th August 2015, 20:03
The FTT and UTT listings don't particularly lend themselves to sorting by DOTAS SRN. I could do a manual search I suppose or go to some less official indices. I'll have a look.

There have been a few hearings that have considered issues like discovery, penalty, etc where a DOTAS number is in evidence.

I'm not sure if the SHIPS schemes were DOTAS registered?

Perhaps a FoI request might be easier?

Freedom Of Information request sent - if nothing else, it will be interesting to see the data...

Boobetty
5th August 2015, 18:28
I'm not sure if the SHIPS schemes were DOTAS registered?

The Charlton/Corfield case was related to a SHIPS scheme and that had a DOTAS SRN. That case was about discovery though and didn't test the legality of the actual DOTAS scheme, but wasn't the Drummond ruling the one that knocked SHIPS schemes into the ether?