Alien vs. Predator

[Jog On]

I haven’t seen this film and what happens in the film aside:

Who do you think would win?

I am of the opinion that Arnie vs. Alien would result in Alien winning. So with that assumption (which may well be incorrect or inaccurate it is just my own opinion) and the fact that Arnie beats the Predator:

If Arnie > Predator

And

Alien > Arnie

Then Alien > Predator

Discuss!

[Churchill]

Predator - They're doing it for sport!

[wobbegong]

Predator - They're doing it for sport!

But if the Alien is killing for survival/food, then the instinct has to be stronger.

(But then again, Arnie is doing it for dollars, which as we all know is a stronger instinct than either of the others.)

[Spacecadet]

The Predator will win

Aliens are suprisingly dumb in comparison and no match for The Predators intelligence, hunting experience and technological superiority.

[The Lone Gunman]

The film is tulip.

1 on 1 Predator walks away with it assuming all weapons and armour are on line.

[Churchill]

The Aliens are bred for sport. Like squirrels!

[ratewhore]

The film is tulip.

A v P Requiem is tuliper than a field of tulip...

[Moscow Mule]

The Predator will win

Aliens are suprisingly dumb in comparison and no match for The Predators intelligence, hunting experience and technological superiority.

IIRC there is a scene in the film where the Aliens win at some point in history (through sheer weight of numbers) and the Predators wipe out the entire planet with some bomb or other to prevent the Aliens from spreading.

Not a great film.

[hyperD]

But if the Alien is killing for survival/food, then the instinct has to be stronger.

(But then again, Arnie is doing it for dollars, which as we all know is a stronger instinct than either of the others.)

However, the Alien doesn't have access to a welfare system, unlike Arnie, and so will be less inclined to develop bingo wings and a distaste for moving off the sofa to forage for reheated food in a stale pizza box.

[gingerjedi]

The major flaw in your argument is assuming that Alien>Arnie... shirley Arnie>Ripley & Ripley>Alien?

Get to da choppa!!!

Arnie pwns all.