So who should Israel give their land back to?

[Mailman]

Seeing as Palestine was never a country anyways...shouldnt the land the Israelies conquored in the 60's be given back to Egypt and Syria?

Mailman

[Fungus]

Seeing as Palestine was never a country anyways...shouldnt the land the Israelies conquored in the 60's be given back to Egypt and Syria?

Mailman

That's a pretty stupid statement.

Some Jews once lived their 2000 years ago so clearly it is all Jewish land. Obvious innit.

[Mailman]

That's a pretty stupid statement.

Some Jews once lived their 2000 years ago so clearly it is all Jewish land. Obvious innit.

Well you and I know that...but try telling that to anyone who is anti-american...opps, sorry...just get so used to typing that...anti-jewish!

Mailman

[TwoWolves]

Flawed Logic

Strictly speaking then Palestine should revert to being a Roman province.

Genetic research, carried out by Jewish scientists indicate that all European Jews are descended from four women who left the region about 2000 years ago. So that entitles them all to a cul-du-sac.

Prior to 1933 4-5% of the region was Jewish, so they should get 4-5% of the land.

The indigenous Arabs (whatever you want to call them) should get the rest.

Seeing as we are applying stupid racist logic today....

I am a descendent of Norman invaders from 1066. My hereditary lands in France where seized by the state at the time of the French Revolution so can I have them back now? Perhaps a Jewish lawyer could take my case to the court of human rights on a no-win, no-fee basis?

[xoggoth]

Fair enough if Kosova is given back to the Serbs, Australia to the Abbos etc.

[Mailman]

The indigenous Arabs (whatever you want to call them) should get the rest.

Seeing as we are applying stupid racist logic today....

I dont think we need to go quite back to the crusades to find the rightful owners...but a mere 40 years to find the most recent owners, this being Egypt or Syria (or who ever else got their arses handed to them in one of those jewish skullcaps! ).

Mailman

[threaded]

And what about Denmark! The Vandals, Angles, Jutes, Saxons etc. all left so who are these people here?

[MrsGoof]

And what about Denmark! The Vandals, Angles, Jutes, Saxons etc. all left so who are these people here?

Pie eaters?

[sunnysan]

And.....

I reckon kick all the white folk out of New Zealand and return the land to the Maoris. In fact kick all the yanks out of america and give the land back to the Indians. Kick all the whites out of Africa etc etc

Possession is 9/10's of the law, society has always worked that way.

[PerlOfWisdom]

I reckon kick all the white folk out of New Zealand and return the land to the Maoris. In fact kick all the yanks out of america and give the land back to the Indians. Kick all the whites out of Africa etc etc

Possession is 9/10's of the law, society has always worked that way.

Yeah, we've got plenty of room for them all to come back here.