• Visitors can check out the Forum FAQ by clicking this link. You have to register before you can post: click the REGISTER link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. View our Forum Privacy Policy.
  • Want to receive the latest contracting news and advice straight to your inbox? Sign up to the ContractorUK newsletter here. Every sign up will also be entered into a draw to WIN £100 Amazon vouchers!

A new Gig and am suspecting Agency dodgy dealings with sign-up

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    A new Gig and am suspecting Agency dodgy dealings with sign-up

    Hi, just received a 6 months offer with a Clientco through one of their large PSL Agencies.

    I am in the process of signing-up for a start date after checks & referencing.

    I am deciding to go either Ltd company or Umbrella.

    If I go Umbrella - the agency say that they are only willing to send the completed contracts to the umbrella company (who I guess can then forward to me). If I go Ltd contract, then the agency is saying they can forward the contract directly to me. Does this make any sense to anyone?

    Have already listened to the agency giving me their speech on Opting out... "Blah, blah, if you opt-out then you can earn more money as you are not restricted in the number of hours you can work, you do want to earn more money?"

    I think this agency has different 'Opt-in' and 'Opt-out' contracts. The Opt-out contract contains terms which do not protect the contractor (e.g. if you don't invoice by a certain time, the agency does not have to pay you).

    The Opt-in contract is generally more protective (I don't want to get in the whole IR35 discussion at this time as I know it is a consideration if ever investigated).

    I have a feeling the Agency is being dodgy and non-transparent with contracts.

    It would like to get the 'Ltd Co' and 'Umbrella' contract versions as well as the 'Opt-in' and 'Opt-out' versions and see what the differences are to make the best call.

    The upfront signing is key to the contract over the long term.

    Anyone had any experience of Agency tactics and the best way to overcome?
    Last edited by pauly; 13 April 2013, 12:40.

    #2
    Don't mention the opt-out.

    Get the limited contract and get it reviewed.

    If you use a solicitor to do the review they will remove all the opt-out clauses for you.

    Btw if you use an umbrella you are legally an employee of the umbrella. No employer shows their employee their agreements with their clients.
    "You’re just a bad memory who doesn’t know when to go away" JR

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by pauly View Post
      It would like to get the 'Ltd Co' and 'Umbrella' contract versions as well as the 'Opt-in' and 'Opt-out' versions and see what the differences are to make the best call.
      I just ask for a copy of their standard contract template so I can review the terms of business. Mostly they are happy to send you one, if they start dicking about then you know they are trying to hide something nasty. They can't force you to opt out if you don't want to but they may try to coerce you by offering crap contract terms if you don't (though the legality of this is debatable).

      I've seen some agencies who have the same contract for opt-in or opt-out and it just marks which sections don't apply (restraint of trade, limits on getting paid if the client doesn't pay, etc) if you don't opt out.
      Free advice and opinions - refunds are available if you are not 100% satisfied.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by SueEllen View Post
        Don't mention the opt-out.

        Get the limited contract and get it reviewed. If you use a solicitor to do the review they will remove all the opt-out clauses for you. Btw if you use an umbrella you are legally an employee of the umbrella. No employer shows their employee their agreements with their clients.
        Meaning the Umbrella could be discussing stuff with the agent behind my back?

        I understand that Umbrellas auto qualify you for protection under AWR whereas Ltd Co's protection is debatable (depends on working practices).

        Hence I was considering the Umbrella approach.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by pauly View Post
          I understand that Umbrellas auto qualify you for protection under AWR whereas Ltd Co's protection is debatable (depends on working practices).

          Hence I was considering the Umbrella approach.
          If the contract has a chance of being outside IR35 then you are much better off to go LTD and stay outside the scope of the AWR.

          If you are going umbrella then get them to arrange the working practices to be inside the AWR and take the benefits.
          Free advice and opinions - refunds are available if you are not 100% satisfied.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by Wanderer View Post
            If the contract has a chance of being outside IR35 then you are much better off to go LTD and stay outside the scope of the AWR.

            If you are going umbrella then get them to arrange the working practices to be inside the AWR and take the benefits.
            FTFY for the benefit of the OP to understand
            'CUK forum personality of 2011 - Winner - Yes really!!!!

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by pauly View Post
              Meaning the Umbrella could be discussing stuff with the agent behind my back?

              I understand that Umbrellas auto qualify you for protection under AWR whereas Ltd Co's protection is debatable (depends on working practices).

              Hence I was considering the Umbrella approach.
              The reason that the contract is sent to the umbrella company is because of the contractual relationship involved - a business to business contract is put in place between the umbrella company and the recruitment agency and you are then employed by the umbrella company under an over-arching contract of employment. Working with an umbrella you will fall under the scope of the AWR but you may also if you have a Ltd Co but are considered a disguised employee i.e. within IR35
              Connect with me on LinkedIn

              Follow us on Twitter.

              ContractorUK Best Forum Advisor 2015

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Wanderer View Post
                If the contract has a chance of being outside IR35 then you are much better off to go LTD and stay outside the scope of the AWR. If you are going umbrella then get them to arrange the working practices to be inside the AWR and take the benefits.
                Thanks for the reply.

                As I basically understand it to-date:

                With a Umbrella...
                - Nothing to worry about with IR35 as you are employed in anycase
                - More able to claim AWR rights from Clientco
                - If your working practices are not employee, AWR protection could be scuppered

                With a Ltd Co...
                - Possible IR35 "disguised employee" issues if investigated by HMRC
                - Less able to claim AWR protection if you are concluded as a business
                - IR35 issues and thus AWR protection dependent on working practices: http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/ir35/guidance.pdf

                Now, consider you are a Ltd Co contractor working on-site like an employee (a lot of people are and many Corporate Clientco expect you to come into the office and work under their direction like an employee)...

                Claiming AWR is likely to be a discussion with the Clientco. IR35 issues are going to be discussions with HMRC. I am unconvinced that anyone is going to be putting the two together. The chances are that you could claim AWR protection if needed with the Clientco hirer by stating you are working like an employee. Practically speaking this would not affect any future IR35 HRMC investigation as they are unlikely to be aware you claimed AWR protection from your Clientco (its two different conversations).

                Thus, it makes sense to be Ltd Co - be able to argue AWR protection if your working practices are employee and (baring any investigations) to be a business for HMRC purposes?

                Capiche??

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by pauly View Post
                  Capiche??
                  Not really, can you bold a couple more items to make it clearer to me please?
                  'CUK forum personality of 2011 - Winner - Yes really!!!!

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Why would a contractor want AWR Protection (whatever you believe it to be)? And do you like 5 month contracts or something?

                    I think you need to do some better research.
                    Blog? What blog...?

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X