New approach to IR35 nets taxman £1.1m

Contractors can now have their say to the taxman on last year’s changes to IR35, in a move that makes good his promise at the last IR35 Forum to want “stakeholders” to feedback on the reforms.

In an update to its website yesterday, HM Revenue & Customs said contractors wanting to submit their views on the new, piloted IR35 processes, including the Business Entity Tests, can use a dedicated email-page.

As well as a PDF listing questions and issues to help focus contractors’ responses, new information on its approach to IR35 was released by HMRC in yesterday’s update, which contractors can use to inform their comments.

In particular, the department says that the 256 IR35 cases launched in 2012-13 have resulted in a tax yield of £1.1million, yet this total includes enquiries into PSCs that began before that tax year.

Eighty-five of the IR35 cases – about a third of the total – resulted in no tax being paid, meaning IR35 was found not to apply, while “many” of the 256 were closed within three months thanks to “customer cooperation”.

The Revenue added: “All [256 IR35 cases] were closed within 12 months, fulfilling HMRC’s commitment to close cases early where on investigation they were low risk.

“Some of the cases opened in 2012-13 are still open and these represent cases where HMRC consider there are still risks that need addressing.”

Employment status advisers are likely to seize on the yield of £1.1m as evidence that the new approach to IR35 – unveiled in May 2012 - is paying off for HMRC, especially as only £220,000 was raised from IR35 enquiries in 2010-2011.

The biggest yearly haul from probing contractors under the rule was in 2005-06 when a total of 656 enquiries generated £2.3m - and is in contrast to the two tax years following IR35’s introduction, both of which returned a tax yield of nil, as the following table shows:

Tax Year No. of Enquiries Total Yield

2000 - 2001



2001 - 2002



2002 - 2003


£946, 275

2003 - 2004



2004 - 2005



2005 - 2006



2006 - 2007



2007 - 2008



2008 - 2009



2009 - 2010



2010 - 2011



2011 - 2012



2012 - 2013



2013 - 14 (to date)


(yet to be disclosed)

Editor's Note: Further Reading - Revenue's IR35 case yield up by 100%
Profile picture for user Simon Moore

Written by Simon Moore

Simon writes impartial news and engaging features for the contractor industry, covering, IR35, the loan charge and general tax and legislation.
Printer Friendly, PDF & Email

Sign up to our Weekly Newsletter

Keep up to date with everything in the world of contracting.


Contractor's Question

If you have a question about contracting please feel free to ask us!

Ask a question