HMRC added 12 new tax schemes to its avoidance ‘naughty list’ in the third quarter of 2026.
The dozen “dodgy” arrangements — as a ContractorUK Forum thread monitoring the list describes them — coincide with HMRC updating three schemes already ‘named and shamed.’
The three existing listees receiving updates are Aura PAYE (first published Dec 2025), Protean (Nov 2024) and Celsius Services (Dec 2025).
Why is HMRC's latest naughty list a ‘stark reminder’ to contractors?
However, Parasol director Ashley Olliver says it’s the 12 new schemes that should serve as a wake-up call for contractors.
“Every time HMRC adds another scheme to its published list, it should serve as a stark reminder to contractors that the risks associated with Disguised Remuneration have not gone away.
“And right now, there are 12 such stark reminders,” Mr Olliver told ContractorUK.
He advised: “Contractors tempted by any promises of unusually high take-home pay should remember the devastating impact that the Loan Charge had on thousands of individuals, who believed they were operating within compliant structures.”
Which 12 tax avoidance schemes has HMRC added?
The 12 new schemes identified by HMRC on “Current list of named tax avoidance schemes, promoters, enablers and suppliers” are (in reverse order of them being added):
- Buckingham Administration (July 2)
- Outsource (July 9)
- Vantage4 (July 30)
- Freeteam
- Kimson Accountancy
- Chartian Management (Aug 13)
- Merium
- Mue Admin HR (Aug 20)
- Novara Nexus
- Invidia (Sep 10)
- Elder Global
- Payeze Contracting
How does the Buckingham Administration scheme claim to work?
Despite being ‘named and shamed’ by HMRC at the very start of Q3, Buckingham Administration’s entry on the avoidance list was last night drawing reaction from experts.
According to HMRC, a user of Buckingham Administration’s scheme contributes to an offshore trust called the Buckingham Administration Co. Ltd Nova Trust 1, the GCWealth Administration LLC Nova Trust 1, “or some other trust.”
The HMRC list follows with an explanation-cum-warning: “Nova Trust deeds include a provision with the claimed effect that any enquiries into the scheme from HMRC will cause the trust to be void from the outset.
“In promotional material, it is claimed that its assets are deemed to be settled on another new trust with the same self-voiding provision, and that HMRC would have to open a new enquiry. HMRC considers this claim to be incorrect and open enquiries into an individual or company remain valid.”
Can a trust deed block an HMRC enquiry?
Carolyn Walsh, a former tax inspector, is often vocal about when HMRC gets it wrong but here, she says the tax office’s assessment appears correct.
“HMRC opens enquiries into tax returns and individuals for specific tax years — not just into a static trust deed,” Walsh, who inspected for the tax authority for eight years, began to ContractorUK.
“A clause inside a private trust deed cannot strip HMRC of its statutory powers under UK tax legislation, such as the Taxes Management Act 1970. And trust deeds cannot override public law.
“In any case, moving assets to a ‘new trust’ would constitute a transfer of value, which itself carries immediate tax consequences of Capital Gains Tax or Stamp Duty.”
Would the courts uphold this ‘Tardis’ trust clause?
Meanwhile, a legal adviser said such a clause is effectively trying to rewrite the past — voiding the trust retroactively once HMRC investigates.
“This is akin to a Tardis provision — ‘If X happens today, then Y happened yesterday.’ Yeah, right,” the legal adviser scoffed.
“Not only that, but I have little doubt that, even if such a provision otherwise might appear to ‘work’ from a purely logical viewpoint — which I’d very much dispute — a doctrine called ‘public policy’ would result in the courts ignoring it.”
Doesn’t HMRC ‘follow the money’ back to contractors, anyway?
Currently advising numerous umbrella companies, the legal adviser also said that such a provision might only succeed in distracting users of the trust from where HMRC’s primary interest would likely lie.
“Why would HMRC need to open an enquiry into a trust in the first place?” the adviser rhetorically asked ContractorUK in a statement. “Wouldn’t the enquiry be opened into the taxpayer who hasn’t (paid tax, that is)? Surely all HMRC have to do is ‘follow the money.’
“And then I can hear HMRC asking: ‘Mr/Ms Contractor: you’ve received this money, please now simply show me where it appears on your self-assessment return, and I’ll go away.’”
How can contractors protect themselves?
In the latest quarter covering the 12 new schemes added to its avoidance blacklist, HMRC published “How to avoid payslip fraud.”
The ten-part guide advises agency workers, temporary workers, contractors and individuals working through an umbrella or payroll company how to check that the tax and National Insurance shown on their payslip or deduction statement has been paid correctly.
Formerly a specialist at the tax office’s National Insurance unit, Carolyn Walsh recommends that any contractor considering using a scheme like the 12 freshly blacklisted by HMRC should first “seek independent advice from a qualified, regulated UK tax professional who is completely independent of the scheme promoter in question.”
When can contractor tax liabilities surface?
Last night (Sep 13th 2026), Parasol’s Ashley Olliver also had a warning for ContractorUK readers: “Tax avoidance schemes can create liabilities that surface many years later, leaving contractors facing significant tax bills, financial hardship and considerable stress.
“The safest approach is to prioritise compliance over short-term gain, carry out thorough ‘due diligence’ and be extremely cautious of any arrangement that appears designed to artificially inflate net pay. The lessons from the Loan Charge remain as relevant today as ever: if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.”

Start the discussion
Working contractors, accountants and recruiters chime in on the issues raised in this article.
No comments yet — be the first to chip in.