The issue was brought to our attention after we examined April 2026 corrective annual statements alongside subsequent demands issued by solicitors Trethowans LLP on behalf of West 28th Street Limited (W28).
The April statements acknowledged failures to comply with section 77A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 and included rebates of interest relating to periods when the required annual statements had not been provided.
Yet the September demands included substantial interest charges, without an accompanying explanation reconciling those figures with the earlier rebates.
More than £21,000 in interest — but at what rate?
Readers may remember Sean, whose story ContractorUK has previously reported. His latest repayment demand totals £131,006.45, comprising £121,300 in alleged outstanding capital and a further £9,706.45 in interest.
His wife has also received demands, totalling £109,223.91, including £11,380.81 in interest on five loans.
Together, the couple are being pursued for £240,230.36, of which £21,087.26 is interest alone.
Both received corrective annual statements in April containing interest rebates.
But the September demands do not appear to specify the percentage interest rates applied, the periods over which interest was calculated, or how the figures reconcile with the April corrections.
Even knowing the original loan amounts and the interest demanded is insufficient to reproduce the calculations. Without the rates, dates and applicable contractual provisions, contractors cannot establish how the totals were reached.
In other words, the demands tell contractors how much interest W28 wants, but not enough about how it was calculated to check the arithmetic.
The law is rather specific
Section 77A(6)(b) of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 provides that borrowers have no liability for interest calculated by reference to periods when the creditor failed to supply the required annual statements.
Providing corrective statements does not retrospectively restore liability for that interest.
Our source, who has detailed knowledge of the original contractor loan arrangements, offered one possible explanation:
"My recollection is that some (but not all) of the loan agreements included a latent interest provision that was not operative at the time of the agreement but could be triggered later by a written demand for interest."
Such provisions may explain why interest appears in later demands. But they do not automatically establish that the amounts claimed are recoverable, nor can they override statutory protections applying to earlier periods of non-compliance.
Interest attributable to periods outside those windows may still be recoverable where the contractual terms permit it.
If W28 pursues disputed interest through the courts, Civil Procedure Rule 16.4 requires a claimant seeking interest to identify the legal basis, rate, calculation dates and amount claimed.
A demand for payment is not, by itself, an explanation of how the debt was calculated.
Other contractors have spotted the problem
The issue has also surfaced on the ContractorUK forum.
In April, one contributor described receiving hundreds of corrective annual statements showing interest rebates, but questioned why the closing balances included unexplained additions to the original loan amounts.
By 2 September, another contributor was asking whether the interest removed in April was now being sought again.
"Am I missing something, or are they now potentially seeking interest which the April statements said had been removed?" the contributor asked.
Is this happening to you?
That's what ContractorUK now wants to establish.
We're looking for contractors who received corrective annual statements in April followed by repayment demands or further correspondence in September or October.
We're particularly interested in the interest rebates, closing balances and subsequent charges, alongside any original agreements or explanations supplied by W28, Ethica Resolve or Trethowans.
If you've challenged an interest calculation and received a response, we'd like to see that too.
ContractorUK has invited Trethowans to comment on the interest issue, and the firm has indicated that a representative will respond.
If you have both sets of correspondence, please get in touch.

Start the discussion
Working contractors, accountants and recruiters chime in on the issues raised in this article.
No comments yet — be the first to chip in.