Contractors' Questions: Should I accept emails as being my contract?

Contractor’s Question: I quit my permie technology-business role only for the company to beg me to stay on for another few months after my official leave date!

I agreed to be hired as a contractor -- albeit as a sole trader -- but after asking for a contract, they said that an email would suffice. Yet the email is not from HR; it’s from the hiring manager and just says the day rate, number of days to be worked and the start date. Should I accept this, as they want me to -- or produce a contract myself and ask them to sign it?

Expert’s Answer: An email may suffice -- but, of course, that entirely depends on what the email says -- and I have not seen it. So, my following comments need to be read with that fact firmly kept in mind.

You haven't actually used the expressions “self-employed” or “paid gross”, but I suspect these are what the question is all about.

To pay a sole trader gross, on the basis of an email containing nothing more than the information given, in circumstances where that sole trader had previously been an employee, is risky -- for them.

The risk is that the taxman would view your employment status as still “employed”, and that as a result, your client would get a bill for the tax they should have deducted from your income. But, as I say, this is their risk, not yours -- it is their door on which the taxman would come knocking.

Some arrangements, similar-sounding to yours, can fall foul of IR35. But IR35 only applies where there is an intermediary -- generally, this would be a company owned by the contractor -- in the middle of the contract chain. It is not a concern for a sole trader working direct for a client.

What you would need to do is to register with HMRC as having commenced self-employment; and then do accounts and a self-assessment return at the end of each tax year. Good luck!

The expert was Roger Sinclair, legal consultant at egos, a contracts advisory for self-employed, freelance and contract professionals.

Wednesday 10th May 2017
Profile picture for user Simon Moore

Written by Simon Moore

Simon writes impartial news and engaging features for the contractor industry, covering, IR35, the loan charge and general tax and legislation.
Printer Friendly, PDF & Email